Attribution Analytics: Five Reports That Show Which Campaigns Deserve More Budget
Attribution analytics earns its keep when it changes a budget decision, and five reports do most of that work: the Optimize report with platform-reported and AdBeacon revenue side by side, first click versus last click by channel, the New vs Returning customer revenue report, the MMM report, and the Creative comparison report. Each one answers a specific question about where the next dollar should go. This post covers what to pull, how to read it, and the move it supports. We leave out assisted conversions, MER, blended ROAS, and lookback windows, since those have their own posts.
Report 1: How big is the difference between platform-reported and AdBeacon revenue?
The Optimize report answers this by showing platform-reported revenue (for example, Meta-reported) next to AdBeacon revenue, so you can see which campaigns have the most overstated ROAS. This is a feature of the Optimize report, not a separate report, and it is the best place to start each review.
What to pull: In Optimize, for each campaign over the last 30 days, compare the platform-reported revenue column with AdBeacon revenue, and note spend.
How to read it: Platforms count conversions their own way. Meta's click-through attribution now counts only conversions after a link click, and engage-through and view-through are counted separately, as Jon Loomer explains. Google also lists timing, attribution settings, and counting rules as causes of data differences. So some difference is normal. One that is big and consistent in a single campaign points to view-through or engage-through credit. For a real example, on one account Meta reported 3.23x ROAS while AdBeacon's click-based measurement showed 0.93x, on the same account and period. That is one account, not a forecast for yours, but it shows why you should check.
A real result from one account. Your gap will differ, which is why you check it every week.
Decision it supports: Rank campaigns by AdBeacon ROAS, not reported ROAS. Cut or hold campaigns whose reported strength disappears under click-based measurement, and move budget to campaigns where the two numbers agree. Our post on why default Meta attribution fails goes deeper on the cause.
Report 2: How much does credit shift between first click and last click?
The first click versus last click view compares each channel's revenue under the two attribution models, and the difference tells you whether a channel starts sales or finishes them. Channels that gain under first click are introducing customers. Channels that gain under last click are closing them.
What to pull: Revenue by channel under first click and under last click, for the same period and the same orders. Switch the attribution model in AdBeacon and read the same channel table twice. Google Ads itself now supports only last click and data-driven models, so the first-click side of this comparison has to come from outside the platform.
Illustrative positions. Run the same table twice in your own account to see your shifts.
How to read it: A prospecting channel that looks mediocre on last click but strong on first click is doing upstream work. A retargeting or brand search channel that dominates last click and nearly disappears on first click is collecting credit for demand that started somewhere else. Because it is a model switch on the same data, this comparison is one click, not a rebuild.
Decision it supports: Protect or grow the channels that gain under first click, even if last-click ROAS looks soft, and cap budgets on channels that mostly harvest. See cross-channel attribution for how to frame these tradeoffs across platforms.
Report 3: How much should you invest in new customers versus returning ones?
The New vs Returning customer revenue report splits attributed revenue into new and returning customers, so you can decide how much to invest in acquisition versus repeat purchase. A channel with strong total ROAS can be mostly returning customers, which means it is not growing your base.
What to pull: New customer revenue and returning customer revenue for the period, by channel, next to spend.
Illustrative split. Low new-customer share plus high spend is the pattern to investigate.
How to read it: Look for channels where new customer share is low but spend is high. Those are often retargeting or remarketing-style campaigns, or acquisition campaigns whose audiences leak existing buyers. A healthy mix depends on your goals: a brand that needs growth wants a rising new customer share, while a brand with a strong repeat base may lean on returning customers.
Decision it supports: Set your split between acquisition and retention spend on purpose, and shift budget toward the channels that bring new customers at a cost you can sustain. Pair it with customer lifetime value so you do not simply chase the cheapest first order.
Report 4: Where should next quarter's budget go? The MMM report
The MMM report is the most important view for budgeting, because it lets you project proposed budgets for future months and quarters instead of only judging past results. AdBeacon integrates Google Meridian for this work, and Meridian is built to produce a budget optimization report that recommends how to allocate spend.
What to pull: Run the MMM report with as much history as you have. We recommend at least two years of data, which gives the model enough seasons to learn from. Treat two years as a recommendation, not a hard minimum.
Illustrative curve. The model estimates yours; treat the projection as a prompt to test.
How to read it: Marketing mix modeling looks at spend and revenue patterns across channels over time, so it can show diminishing returns that a single-day attribution view hides. Test a proposed budget for next month or next quarter and compare the projected outcome with your current plan. Models give estimates, so treat the output as a prompt to test, not proof.
Decision it supports: Choose a budget split for the coming quarter, then move money in measured steps and check results as they arrive. Our posts on MMM vs attribution vs incrementality and using MMM insights to shift budgets explain how to put the output to work.
Report 5: Which creative types move the needle? The Creative comparison report
The Creative comparison report shows which creative types drive higher ROAS and profitability, so you can guide creative budget toward what works.
What to pull: Creative types compared on ROAS and profitability, over a period long enough to cover several ad refreshes.
How to read it: Look for creative types that lead on both ROAS and profitability, not just one. A type with high ROAS but thin profitability may not deserve more budget. Compare the leaders against the types that only win on attention metrics. Our guide on finding the most effective Facebook creatives covers the creative side in more depth.
Decision it supports: Put more creative budget into the types that lead, brief your next round of production around them, and retire the types that fall behind.
How do you turn five reports into one weekly routine?
Run them in a fixed order and write down one decision per report. Start with the Optimize report to clean up the numbers, then first click versus last click and New vs Returning to decide what each channel is for, then the MMM and Creative comparison reports to decide where to move money.
- Optimize Weekly
- First vs last click Monthly
- New vs Returning Monthly
- MMM At planning
- Creative comparison Monthly
| Report | What changed | What we will do |
|---|---|---|
| Optimize | One sentence | One sentence |
| First vs last | One sentence | One sentence |
| New vs Returning | One sentence | One sentence |
| MMM | One sentence | One sentence |
| Creative | One sentence | One sentence |
- Pull all five from the same date range and the same settings. AdBeacon lets you set any window, with or without a comparison to the previous period.
- Write one sentence per report: what changed and what you will do.
- Change a small number of budgets each time, so you can tell which move caused which result.
- To dig into one result, use the Customer Journey report (the cart icon in Optimize) for every touchpoint per order, plus the Orders and Product reports.
The point of attribution analytics is fewer, better budget calls, not more dashboards. If you want to see these reports on your own data, book a demo with AdBeacon.
FAQ
What is the most important attribution report for budget decisions?
For forward-looking budgets, the MMM report matters most, and the Optimize report is the best first step each review, because it shows which campaign numbers you can trust. Every other decision depends on that.
How often should I review attribution analytics reports?
Weekly for the Optimize report, and monthly for first click versus last click, new versus returning, and creative comparison. Review the MMM report when you plan a month or quarter. Shorter cycles mostly add noise.
Why does first-click credit matter if last click converts?
Last click shows who closed the sale, while first click shows who started the journey. Cutting a first-click channel because last click looks weak can shrink your pipeline later.
Can these reports prove a campaign is incremental?
No. They point you to where to test, but only a holdout or geo test shows incrementality. Attribution credits the ads that came before a sale whether or not they made any difference, which is exactly what a lift test checks. Use the reports to decide which campaigns deserve a test.