Search
Close this search box.

Understanding Channel Impact and Attribution in Your Ad Campaigns: Our Insights

Navigating Digital Advertising Channels: Our Approach

In our journey through the intricate world of digital advertising, one of the foremost challenges we’ve faced is aligning the performance metrics of various advertising channels with the revenue data from e-commerce platforms like Shopify or BigCommerce. 

Our approach has been to focus on first-party data, which has proven to be a game-changer in offering accurate and reliable insights. This method allows us to make well-informed decisions based on solid data, enhancing the effectiveness of our campaigns.

What You Can Do:

Regular Data Reconciliation: Frequently cross-check data from your advertising platforms and e-commerce systems to spot inconsistencies. 

Facebook and Google are notorious for claiming success for the same conversion – and optimizing off of double-counted data is going to quickly burn up ad spend. 

 

First-Party Data Utilization: Prioritize first-party data for more accurate insights into your channel performance. 

Tie your e-commerce store conversions directly to your campaigns, ads, and ad sets to ensure you are tracking (and scaling) accurately.

cycri2015_logo_lighthouse_on_circuit_board_binary_code_in_the_b_9fffa3d0-d6fc-4959-ac6e-eec37f0e7db8

The Importance of Channel Impact Analysis

Our experience has highlighted the critical role of understanding the impact of each channel within the omni-channel ecosystem. It’s not just about tracking performance metrics; it’s about comprehensively analyzing how each channel contributes to the customer journey from awareness to purchase. 

This deep understanding enables us to allocate resources more effectively and craft strategies that resonate at each stage of the consumer funnel.

What You Can Do:

Detailed Funnel Analysis: Perform a detailed analysis of your marketing funnel to identify the most effective channels at different stages. 

Look at EVERYTHING and don’t just base an optimization pivot on just a “last click attribution” model – there is always more driving the conversion. 

Conversion Path

Comprehensive Customer Journey Mapping: Create detailed maps of your customers’ journey, highlighting key touchpoints and their influence on consumer behavior. 

We see this all the time, a massive amount of TOF action on paid social campaigns and then MOF and BOF on organic and direct. Knowing this flow will let you plan and build REAL strategies.

Adbeacon revenue

Tackling Revenue Reporting Discrepancies

A recurring theme in our work is the challenge of reconciling revenue reporting discrepancies between different ad platforms and actual e-commerce figures. 

By offering a consistent and unified view of data across all channels, we strive to minimize these discrepancies, ensuring that our strategies are based on the most accurate data available. This approach is crucial for reliable decision-making and maximizes the impact of our advertising spend.

What You Can Do:

Integrated Analytics Platforms: Use integrated analytics platforms to consolidate data from different sources for a unified view. 

More specifically (your) third-party e-commerce data that is attributed to campaigns, ad sets, and ads. Nail down the accuracy – then scale to the moon. 

Revenue by channel over time

In-depth Attribution Analysis: Regularly analyze and adjust your attribution models to ensure they accurately reflect the customer journey and channel contributions. We have said it a million times – you need to know the whole story to build a strategy. 

Don’t just stick with the attribution model that makes you “feel good” – use the models that will drive profits and revenues.

Touchpoints to orders

Decoding Attribution Models: Our Linear Approach

In our approach to attribution, we’ve found linear modeling to be particularly insightful. This model assigns equal importance to each interaction along the customer’s journey, recognizing the collective impact of all touchpoints on the path to conversion. This method has helped us align our reported revenues with the actual figures in our CRM, leading to more strategic and informed budget allocations.

What You Can Do:

Experiment with Different Attribution Models: Test various attribution models to see which aligns best with your business goals. 

Each model gives you channel and funnel insights that will let you allocate your paid (and organic) investments more accurately. 

Attribution model dropdown

Balance Across Touchpoints: Ensure that your attribution model fairly represents the impact of all customer interactions. 

The customer journeys we see every day would make your head explode, 5, 10, and 15 touchpoints for one conversion are all too common. Focus on the touchpoints that are causing friction and smooth them over.

Performance trend

Leveraging the Attribution Tab:
Insights from Our Experience

Utilizing an ‘attribution tab’, akin to GA4, has been a cornerstone of our strategy. It offers profound insights into the effectiveness of different channels at each stage of the sales funnel. This data-driven approach allows us to refine our campaigns for optimal performance and continually adapt our strategies based on evolving customer behavior.

What You Can Do:

Regular Reporting and Analysis: Set up regular reporting schedules to stay updated on channel performance and customer behavior trends. 

Seasonality, promotional periods, or even economic shifts can change the game – so keep your head on a swivel rather than in the sand. 

New vs returning customer by channel graphic

Customized Dashboard Usage: Employ customized dashboards to visualize data effectively and derive actionable insights. Focus on the metrics that matter for your brand and business model. 

For example, e-commerce and lead gen have very different KPIs – so make sure you track what matters for you, not someone else.

Attribution model

Understanding Channel Roles:
Our Perspective

Our analysis of different channels, such as paid social and direct traffic, under various attribution models has shed light on the nuanced roles these channels play. For instance, we’ve observed that paid social is excellent for creating initial awareness, while direct traffic often plays a crucial role in the final conversion stage. 

Understanding these intricate dynamics is key to optimizing our advertising efforts.

What You Can Do:

Channel Performance Assessment: Regularly assess the performance of each channel to understand its role in the customer journey. 

It’s easy to miss the effect your paid campaigns can have on organic ones – be sure to zoom out and look at the greater impact from time to time so you can see what is happening.

New vs returning customer by channel graphic

Holistic Campaign Evaluation: Look beyond immediate conversion metrics to evaluate the overall impact of each campaign. 

This includes watching your LTV and returning customer numbers, remember, it is far easier (and cheaper) to bring a customer back than it is to keep churning and burning new customers.

Customer retention analysis

Integrating Campaigns for
Comprehensive Funnel Movement

Our analysis of different channels, such as paid social and direct traffic, under various attribution models has shed light on the nuanced roles these channels play. 

For instance, we’ve observed that paid social is excellent for creating initial awareness, while direct traffic often plays a crucial role in the final conversion stage. Understanding these intricate dynamics is key to optimizing our advertising efforts.

What You Can Do:

Campaign Integration Planning: Plan your campaigns with a focus on how each element interacts with and supports others throughout the funnel: organic traffic, landing pages, email campaigns, etc.

Revenue by channel

Funnel Stage Optimization: Tailor your campaigns to effectively address the needs and behaviors of customers at each stage of the funnel. 

Remember MOST often customers do not enter and convert on the same channel.

Channel Orders by channel

Final Thoughts - Is AdBeacon For You?

We believe in empowering our strategies with robust data and insights, ensuring each decision is data-driven. As the digital advertising landscape continues to evolve, we remain committed to staying at the forefront of these changes, continuously refining our methods to maximize efficiency and revenue generation. 

There are a lot of angles to keep your eye on, as you can see from what we have outlined above. AdBeacon was created to address all these challenges – because we were built by media buyers! 

We know the challenges that agencies face and we would love to help you solve them. Consider booking a demo with us by clicking here and we will show you what’s possible.